Keeping the family home during a divorce feels like the right move, especially when children are still in school and life already feels uncertain. However, the home comes with costs that go far beyond the mortgage. Before committing to keeping the property, understanding the real financial cost upfront can prevent a decision that creates long-term hardship.
How Illinois treats the marital home
Illinois follows equitable distribution, meaning courts divide marital property fairly rather than necessarily equally. The state presumes any home acquired during the marriage is marital property, regardless of whose name is on the deed. As a result, keeping the home typically means formally buying out your spouse’s share. A home owned before the marriage or received as a gift or inheritance is generally non-marital. However, marital funds used toward it may give your spouse a partial claim.
The mortgage refinancing challenge
Removing your spouse from the mortgage requires refinancing the loan in your name alone. Lenders evaluate your individual income, credit score and debt-to-income ratio during this process. On a single income, qualifying can mean accepting a higher interest rate or a smaller loan amount. The result is often a significantly higher monthly payment than what two incomes once covered.
Ongoing costs beyond the mortgage
The mortgage is only part of homeownership. Property taxes, homeowner’s insurance, utilities and repairs all fall to one person once the household runs on a single income. Illinois offers property tax relief through the General Homestead Exemption, but those savings rarely cover the full cost of maintenance. Calculating the actual monthly total before committing to the home is critical.
Tax implications of keeping the home
If the home sells in the future, capital gains taxes may apply to the profit. Single filers can exclude up to $250,000 in profit from federal taxes, but the IRS taxes anything above that. Illinois also taxes capital gains as ordinary income under the Illinois Income Tax Act. A home that seems manageable today may carry a significant tax burden when you eventually sell.
Trading home equity for other assets
Keeping the home typically requires giving up other marital assets in exchange. Retirement funds and savings accounts are common trade-offs. 529 college savings accounts funded during the marriage count as marital assets, but courts generally restrict those funds to educational expenses rather than open division. In such cases, giving up liquid assets to keep the home can leave your overall financial picture at a serious disadvantage.
Protect your financial future first
Keeping the home should strengthen your financial future, not strain it. Before agreeing to anything, compare the total cost of homeownership against your income, your remaining marital assets and your long-term savings goals. A clear financial assessment can protect you from a decision that becomes a burden later.
